Without audience, nothing begins
Article 4 of 14 in series: The Great Reach Reset
Reach is the prerequisite. Creative is the multiplier.
Last week, I came across a post from Julien Rosanvallon, Deputy Chief Executive Officer at Médiamétrie, after he spoke about attention at a France Télévisions conference. What caught my attention wasn’t a new metric or a new model, but something much simpler. He described advertising effectiveness as a layered structure: audience at the base, then attention, and then emotion.
He summed it up in one clear statement: without audiences, there is no attention, no emotion, and no effectiveness.
It struck me because, in many modern marketing discussions, we tend to jump straight to the top of that structure. We talk about emotional storytelling, brand love, attention metrics and creative excellence. All of that is important. But none of it can exist without the foundation. Reach may not be the most exciting topic in marketing, but it remains the starting point.
Byron Sharp’s work has consistently reminded us that brands grow through penetration. And penetration is fundamentally about being present in the buying universe – not just among loyal customers or high-intent audiences, but across the category. You cannot build mental availability among people who have never encountered your brand. In that sense, reach is not the objective, but the prerequisite.
It is also sometimes argued – and Nielsen’s earlier research has also shown – that creative quality remains the single largest driver of short-term sales lift. I do not disagree. Strong creative matters enormously. But the question is not which lever contributes most within a campaign. The more fundamental question is what determines whether growth is even possible in the first place. Creative determines how strongly you influence the people you reach. Reach determines how many future buyers you have the opportunity to influence at all. These are not contradictory perspectives; they operate at different levels of the system. Creative explains variance in performance within exposure. Reach explains the size of the growth opportunity itself. And in a fragmented media environment, ensuring incremental reach across the market has become both more difficult.
Scale inside one channel is not the same as scale in the market
The challenge is that, in today’s fragmented media environment, reach is harder to interpret. Every channel reports strong numbers. Every campaign appears to deliver scale. On the surface, it can look as though growth is simply a matter of investing enough. But scale inside channels is not the same as scale in the market.
If the same audiences are repeatedly exposed across multiple environments, what appears to be reach may actually be duplication. And while frequency can reinforce memory, it does not expand the buyer base on its own. If we are serious about penetration, what matters is incremental reach – the ability to extend exposure beyond the same pool of consumers.
Creative multiplies reach, but cannot replace it
This is where the conversation about creatives becomes essential.
As Julien points out, reach alone does not create effectiveness. It creates the possibility of effectiveness. Attention and emotion are what turn exposure into memory, and memory into future choice. Great creative amplifies that process. It increases the likelihood that an exposure is noticed, processed, and retained. In that sense, creative multiplies the value of reach.
But creative cannot compensate for the absence of scale. And reach cannot compensate for weak creative. That is why the debate between reach and creative is misplaced. They are not competing priorities. They are interdependent components of the same system.
For CMOs and brand leaders, the real challenge is not choosing one over the other. It is understanding how audience, attention, and emotion connect to drive effectiveness – and ensuring that reach is genuinely expanding the future buyer base, not simply reinforcing familiarity within a limited group.
Without audience, nothing begins. Without incremental reach, nothing grows. And without strong creative, nothing endures. In my opinion, we can debate attention models and creative awards all we want. But if the audience is not growing, neither is the brand. Growth begins with reach.
This article is 4 of 14 in our series: The Great Reach Reset
About this article series
In a fragmented media landscape, reach is no longer a simple KPI - it is a strategic growth lever. In this article series, AudienceProject explores why advertisers are not failing at reach, but at measuring it properly, and why incremental, deduplicated cross-media reach has become essential to driving penetration, controlling frequency, and unlocking sustainable growth.
You might also like:
189 years later, advertising still comes down to trust and incremental reach
Disrupt or die – now from inside the advertising industry
Video killed the radio star – or did it really?
From channels to journeys: Why cross-media measurement matters more than ever
I want desirability…
I’m not a creative. But I respect the multiplier.
Signup for the AudienceProject newsletter
Industry relevant articles, truth-revealing studies, exiting new product launches and random thoughts from brilliant people - directly in your inbox. Free of charge and no spam guaranteed!